Notes:

ESTATE OF BEEBEE
118 Cal.App.2d 851 (1953)
Court of Appeals of California, First District, Division One.
July 1, 1953.




There is no conflict in the testimony, the claimed conflict being in the inferences to be drawn therefrom and in the construction of the letter. Decedent was a woman 89 years of age, growing blind, and while in good health, was not strong. She had one son, Ralph A. Beebee, who predeceased her by two days, and two grandsons, Ralph A. Beebee, Jr., the child of Ralph Sr. and his first wife, and Robert A. Beebee, a minor, the son of Ralph Sr. and his second wife, who after her divorce remarried and is Mrs. Irene Meniktos. Ralph Jr. disappeared around 1930, was never afterwards heard of by decedent, and was disinherited. Decedent had deposited with the Wells Fargo Bank and Union Trust Company, the executor and trustee under the will and codicil originally admitted to probate, a will made in 1940. On April 26, 1944, Mr. Falconer, one of the attorneys for the bank, drew a will for decedent which she executed. This will left a piano to her grandson Robert, and the rest of her furniture to her son Ralph Sr. The rest of her estate was to be converted into cash, an endowment policy for $500 on Robert's life to be purchased, and the balance used to procure a life annuity for Ralph Sr. In the event of his death, prior to the purchase of the annuity, the estate was to go to Bertha Richardson, Ralph Sr.'s wife by his first marriage, Evelyn Jacobs, a protegee, Elizabeth B. Snell, Lillian James Larson and Josephine Woolf, intimate friends. This will was deposited with the bank. From time to time the trust department sent out notices to decedent, as well as others, to look over their present wills to see if they desired to make changes. On July 3, 1947, decedent drew a codicil dated that day, which read, "I, Sarah A. Beebee, bequeath to my grandson, Ralph Augustus Beebee, $10.00." It was signed by her. This she sent Mr. Falconer in a letter in which she asked if it could be legally attached to her will, and if not what she could do to make it legal. July 7th Mr. Falconer wrote her to the effect that the proposed codicil was legal but suggested that in view of the reasons she had given in her letter for limiting her grandson Ralph Jr. to only $10, she sign a codicil which contained a "non-contest clause," form of which he enclosed. He suggested that if she could not come to his office she copy the form in her own handwriting. This she did, dated it July 8th, and sent it to be, and it was, deposited with the bank. According to Mrs. Snell, a close friend of decedent, when decedent had anything to write that was important,
[ 118 Cal.App.2d 855 ]

she would first write a draft of it, then rewrite it, sometimes making minor changes. She would keep the first draft as a copy. She also told Mrs. Snell many times, even as late as within two weeks of her death, that she would be afraid to make a will without an attorney's advice. Prior to 1950 Ralph Sr., having been divorced from his second wife, returned to live with decedent in the home which she owned. In March, 1950, Ralph Sr. was engaged in the contracting business and needed money. Decedent had given him all she could to help him, and through him, had put her property up for sale so as to get more money for him. The sale did not go through. About March 14th, Mr. Scott received the following letter (exhibit 1):
"#1318 ? 43rd Ave San Francisco Mar 11th 1950

Wells Fargo Bank and Union Trust Company
Market at Montgomery St, San Francisco
Mr. Robert T. Scott
Manager Estate Planning Division

Dear Mr. Scott:
"Conditions have changed making it desirable that I revoke all former wills and codicils made by me, and wish to leave my entire estate to my son, Ralph Agustus Beebee without reservations. I am 89 years old, Helpless and growing blind. Please help me either to add a new codicil or to make a new will
Sarah Agusta Beebee
dated Mar 11th 1950"

Family/Spouse: Donna Claire Heck. Donna was born on 6 Jul 1922 in Kansas, USA; died on 3 Mar 2011 in Topeka, Shawnee County, Kansas, USA; was buried in Mount Hope Cemetery, Topeka, Shawnee County, Kansas, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

1. Kristy Beebee

Ralph married Gladys Madie Ireland on 28 Dec 1914 in Missouri, USA, and was divorced. Gladys (daughter of George H. Ireland and Martha M. Yockey) was born on 8 Dec 1894 in Newton, Jasper County, Iowa, USA; died in 0Aug 1977 in Topeka, Shawnee County, Kansas, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

George married Martha M. Yockey in 1892. Martha (daughter of Carl Jacky Yockey and Belinda Okey) was born on 27 Dec 1864 in Monroe County, Ohio, USA; died on 14 Feb 1939 in Kansas City, Jackson County, Missouri, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

Carl married Belinda Okey in 1852 in Stafford, Monroe County, Ohio, USA. Belinda was born on 8 Jul 1835 in Woodsfield, Monroe County, Ohio, USA; died on 27 Jul 1913 in Emmetsburg, Palo Alto County, Iowa, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]